The history of the First United Methodist Church (FUMC) in Watertown, New York, is marked by a legacy of resilience and dedication to faith. The journey began in 1804 when the first Methodist class was organized in the home of Simeon Woodruff. The church officially incorporated as the First Methodist Episcopal Church in 1823, and the first church building was erected at the intersection of Arsenal and Massey Streets.

Key Milestones:

• 1851: A new building was constructed on Arsenal Street near the Armory.
• 1880: The building was destroyed by fire and subsequently rebuilt on the same site.
• 1942: Another fire completely destroyed the church. During this period, the congregation worshiped at other local churches.
• 1943: The congregation acquired and remodeled the carriage house of the Taylor mansion into a house of worship, which was dedicated the same year.
• 1958: The cornerstone for a new sanctuary was laid.
• 1959: The new worship space officially opened, providing a stable home for the congregation.

Through trials and triumphs, the congregation of First UMC Watertown has shown remarkable endurance and faithfulness, establishing a strong and God-centered community that continues to thrive and serve.